By Hridoy Ahmed | Last updated: November 2026 | 11 min read
Short answer: A soft 404 is a page that looks “not found” or empty to Google, but still answers with a normal 200 status code. Google does not index it. Fix it with one of three responses: a real 404 or 410 if the page is gone, a 301 redirect to a close replacement, or real content if the page should exist.
In this guide
- What a soft 404 means
- When a soft 404 is a problem
- The 3-question decision
- How to see what Google sees
- Common causes on WordPress sites
- How to fix each type
- Validate the fix and wait
- Mistakes that make it worse
- FAQ
What a soft 404 means
Every URL answers a request with a status code. A 404 says “this page was not found”. A 200 says “everything is fine, here is the page”. A soft 404 is a mismatch between the two. The code says 200, but the page says “nothing here”, or shows almost no content at all.
Google reads the page, decides it behaves like an error page, and lists it in Search Console under Indexing, then Pages, then Not indexed with the reason “Soft 404”. The word “soft” means the server did not send the 404 code itself. Google worked it out from the content.
| Real 404 | Soft 404 | Redirect to homepage | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Status code | 404 or 410 | 200 | 301 or 302 |
| What the visitor sees | A “not found” page | A “not found” or empty page | Your homepage |
| What Google understands | The page is gone | Mixed signals | May be treated as a soft 404 if the homepage is not a real replacement |
| Indexed? | No, and crawled less over time | No | Not the old URL |
Google’s crawler documentation describes the same idea. A 2xx response is passed on for processing, and if the content looks like an empty page or an error message, Search Console reports a soft 404.
When a soft 404 is a problem
Not every soft 404 needs panic. Google says it is fine for a URL to stay out of the index for the right reasons. So the first question is which URL we are talking about.
- Harmless: a URL you deleted on purpose, an empty tag archive, an old test page. Google will not index it, and nothing you want is lost. You still fix it for clean signals, but it is not urgent.
- A real problem: an important page flagged as soft 404. Google will not show it in search, so you lose traffic from that page.
- A template problem: hundreds of similar URLs flagged at once. This usually means one rule on your site creates empty pages.
- A user problem: visitors land on a dead-end page that pretends to be fine. They leave, and your site looks unmaintained.
The report also shows a Source value. For soft 404 it is “Website”, which means the cause sits on your side and you can fix it.
The 3-question decision
Do not fix soft 404s one by one in the order of the list. Answer three questions for each group of URLs.
- Should this URL exist at all? If no, return a real 404 or 410 and remove the links that point to it.
- Is there a close replacement? If yes, 301 redirect to that exact page. If no, go back to the 404.
- Is it a real page that Google reads as empty? Then the page needs more useful content, or Google cannot load the content that is there.
This table covers the situations I see most often.
| Situation | Best response | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| Deleted page, no replacement | 404 or 410, remove internal links | Redirect to the homepage |
| Page moved or merged | 301 to the closest matching page | Redirect to a loosely related page |
| Product temporarily out of stock | Keep 200, show stock status and similar products | A page with only “unavailable” |
| Product discontinued, similar item exists | 301 to that item or its category | Redirect every old product to the shop page |
| Product discontinued, nothing similar | 404 or 410 | Keeping a thin page alive |
| Empty category or tag archive | Remove the term, or noindex the archive | An indexable archive with no posts |
| Internal search with no results | Noindex, keep it out of the sitemap | Letting empty results be indexed |
| Short site maintenance | 503 status with a Retry-After header | A “back soon” page that returns 200 |
| Real page with very little text | Add useful content, merge or remove it | Padding it with filler text |
How to see what Google sees
Take five minutes before you change anything. You need proof of what the server sends and what Google renders.
- Open Indexing, then Pages and click “Soft 404”. The examples table lists up to 1,000 URLs. Export it if you need the full pattern.
- Click the inspect icon next to one URL. Run Test live URL, then View tested page. Look at the screenshot and the HTML. Does Google see your content, or a blank shell?
- Check the status code the server sends. In Chrome, open DevTools, go to the Network tab and reload. Or run this command on any computer with a terminal.
curl -I https://example.com/old-page/
Read the first line of the answer. A page that is truly gone should show 404 or 410. A real page should show 200.
- If the page looks fine to you but blank in Google’s screenshot, check the resources section of the live test. Blocked scripts, failed API calls and slow JavaScript can leave Google with an empty page.
- Test a fake URL such as
https://yourdomain.com/this-page-does-not-exist-123/. It should return 404. If it returns 200 with a friendly message, your whole site creates soft 404s by design.
Hundreds of flagged URLs and no time to sort them? My technical SEO service starts with exactly this triage, using your Search Console data and a crawl.
Common causes on WordPress sites
- A 404 template that returns 200. Some themes, page builders and redirect plugins show a custom “not found” design but send the wrong status code. The fake URL test above catches this.
- Empty archives. Tag, category, author and date archives with no posts. Paginated pages beyond the last page also fall here.
- Internal search pages. URLs with
?s=and zero results read like error pages. - Placeholder pages. “Coming soon”, “Thank you” pages with one line, test pages and empty landing pages.
- Mass redirects to the homepage. After a cleanup, many old URLs point to one page that has nothing to do with them.
- Maintenance mode that returns 200. The site says “we will be back soon” while telling Google everything is fine.
- Content that fails to load. The page depends on a script or API, the call fails for Googlebot, and only the frame remains.
- Dead URLs in the sitemap. A sitemap that lists removed pages keeps pointing Google at them. Check your XML sitemap.
How to fix each type
The page should be gone
Delete it, or move it to the trash, and let the server return 404 or 410. Google treats these two codes the same way, so use whichever your setup makes easy. Then remove the URL from your sitemap and remove internal links to it. Links to a dead page keep sending visitors and crawlers into a wall. My guide on finding and fixing broken links shows how.
The page moved
Use a 301 redirect to the specific new page. Google treats a 301 as a strong signal that the target is the new home of the content. A 302 is a weak signal, so do not use it for permanent moves. In Rank Math, the Redirections module lets you pick the redirect type for each URL, including 410. After you set it up, test it with my guide on checking redirects so you do not create chains.
The page is real, but Google reads it as empty
Ask what a searcher expects to find on this URL. Then check whether the page delivers it in plain HTML. View the page source. If your main text is missing there, Google may depend on JavaScript to see it. Add the useful content: facts, steps, examples, answers to follow-up questions. If you cannot add anything real, merge the page into a stronger one and redirect it.
A template creates empty pages
Fix the rule, not each URL. Rank Math has options under Titles and Meta to noindex search results and empty archives. Remove tags you never use. For a store, decide how out-of-stock and discontinued products behave, using the table above.
Maintenance mode returns 200
For a short maintenance window, the correct answer is a 503 status, which tells Google the site is temporarily unavailable. Check your maintenance plugin with the curl command. If it returns 200, change its setting or use a different plugin. Keep the window short, because Google drops URLs that return server errors for a long time.
Validate the fix and wait
After you fix every URL in the group, open the Soft 404 issue and click Validate fix. A few rules from Google’s help pages save you trouble:
- Fix all known instances first. If Google finds one remaining instance, validation stops.
- Do not click Validate fix again until the first run succeeds or fails.
- Validation usually takes up to about two weeks, and sometimes longer.
- If a URL is gone, noindexed or blocked, Google counts the issue as fixed for that URL.
- An issue leaves the table about 90 days after the last instance disappears.
You do not have to click the button. Google updates the count whenever it recrawls an affected URL.
Mistakes that make it worse
- Redirecting all dead URLs to the homepage. It hides the problem and may create new soft 404s.
- Padding a dead page with filler text. It keeps a useless page alive and wastes crawl effort.
- Blocking the URLs in robots.txt. The report goes quiet, but the cause stays. Google also cannot see your fix.
- Requesting indexing for every flagged URL. It does not change what the page returns or contains.
- Fixing the wrong group first. Start with important pages, then templates, then leftovers.
If the page is real but never gets indexed, read why a page is not indexed by Google and Crawled – currently not indexed.
FAQ
Does a soft 404 hurt my SEO?
The flagged URL will not rank, because it is not indexed. If the page is junk, you lose nothing. If it is an important page, you lose its traffic until you fix it.
What is the difference between a 404 and a soft 404?
A 404 is a status code that the server sends. A soft 404 is a judgment by Google about a page that returns 200 but behaves like an error page.
Should I redirect soft 404 pages to my homepage?
Usually no. Redirect only when the target is a real replacement for the old content. If there is no replacement, return 404 or 410.
How long does a soft 404 take to clear?
Google needs to recrawl each URL first. Validation usually takes about two weeks, and it can take longer on large sites.
Soft 404s on pages that matter? I check the status codes, the rendering and the template rules by hand, then give you a fix list. See my SEO and technical SEO service.
About the author: Hridoy Ahmed is an SEO specialist and WordPress security expert based in Dhaka, Bangladesh. He has 8+ years of experience and works with clients worldwide.
